UESP Forums

i think so, all the 'saving the doctor' stuff has happened in her own personal time line already so there's no reason why the doc can't drop her back to her stationery cupboard, say bye bye and they never talk to each other again

just saw the heist one, havent watched robot of sherwood though

Matt Smith and David Tenent were both energetic enthusiastic doctors whith issues yes but yuou knew what pushed their buttons

i dont get a sense of Capaldi Doc at all - what does he like, is he just going through the motions of being clever, if a bit callous (which is fine, plenty of Dr Who's have been like that, in fact Smith and Tenent were pretty much the first ones to properly wear "save the humans" t shirts, as it were)

there's something missing, it was another episode where they avoided the situation where we meet him as a 'real person'

'The Caretaker' was bonkers but i liked it a lot, i suppose they read my last post and went back a few months in time to make an episode with 3 solid roles and lots of character development

Spoilers for Dark Water.

For Calpadi's first series, it's been rather good and it definitly beats a few of Smith's series. The writing has given Calpadi more to work with and I'm glad Moffat has decided to scale back his involvement with the writing. He has written a few episodes but if i remember correctly, a majority of the episodes were written by other members of the writing team.

Has this really not been posted in since last year!? Wow.

My wife has recently started watching Doctor Who, starting with the Ninth Doctor. It's fun to watch her watch and see her reactions to everything. She loves the stylistic choices so far, and the theme of space/time exploration. At the end of the season she texted me "The Doctor changed!" So fun.

She's also planning on decorating her classroom with a space theme and including aspects of Doctor Who in it, including decorating a structural column in her wall as the TARDIS. Going to be so fun!

Anyway, I've only seen the first episode of the last season, and the rest of it comes to Netflix and Hulu next week. I'll probably be binge watching throughout the month.

Basically, Musicman, Number 12 is a bit of a grouchy old man that does it his way. It's a far better season and whilst some episodes are a bit lacklustre or have that one "Oh [&@%!] off," moment, it's far better then Smith's first season.

Also, Capaldi's second season is due to happen soon! Hopefully, Moffat will continue to let others write and not hog it all to himself as i think that what caused a majority of Smith's episodes to be a bit "oh god" and "Oh [&@%!] off" with a dash of "MARY SUE! [&@%!] OFF! I HATE THIS, HATE THIS, MAKES NO SENSE! [&@%!] YOU RIVER YOU WALKING PLOT DEVICE! AAAAAAAAARGGGGGGGGGGH"

Ahem,

I think it's safe to say i hate River Song because she is a mary sue.

I do hope Jack will return soon and the Doctor's Daughter will return as they are doing nothing with them. I think they wanted to give the daughter a spin off but couldn't get the funding approved or felt it wasn't worth it. Torchwood is dead thanks to the average whatever it was called. I mean, i literally guessed the entire plot twist by the end of the second episode and it made no [&@%!] sense as Jack is a fixed point in time not part of planet earth! What the [&@%!] were they thinking? Seriously? Just [&@%!] you Torchwood writers of [&@%!] day! [&@%!] YOU AND YOUR [&@%!] PLOT!

Ahem, sorry. I seem to be growing an inner angry critic. :O

Just seen the first advert for it on BBC3 and it looks like this will be an excellent season! It starts on 19th September in the UK. I'm unsure if BBC broadcasts it on BBC america during the same run period or does it later down the line but it is worth watching!

[&@%!], just forgot what else i spotted.

Hell yeah I'm looking forward to it coming back.

But no, I don't think Moffat is a great showrunner, he was much better at writing individual episodes. Also back then he'd have an editor and producer above him in case he did anything silly. A good example of poor continuity on Moffat's part is The Doctor's regenerations. In Let's Kill Hitler The Doctor is alone with the TARDIS who tells him that he's dying because he's been poisoned. And the Doctor is like cool, regeneration time then. And the TARDIS tell him that no, it's super poison so you can't regenerate. But wouldn't they both know he can't regenerate anyway? Well no, because Moffat hadn't come up with the War Doctor yet. Also the Doctor acts really weird sometimes like how 11 forcefully kisses Rory and Jenny without consent. I just don't see sexual assault as something The Doctor would do.

I agree. Moffat's stories for a few of Smith's seasons were [&@%!]. I mean, rebooting the universe? River [&@%!] Song being a deus ex machina on more then one occassion? Rory coming back from non-existence? Just no. I think Moffat may have been forced to let others write for Calpadi's first series either by Calpadi himself or the higher ups as i have heard he is not the type to put up with any [&@%!].

Also, River Song needs to never appear in Dr Who again. Sorry, i just really hate the mary sue on steroids that is River Song.

Thinking about the War Doctor, he doesn't really fit in. I know it's something Moffat had to do at the last moment due to Christopher E-who's last name i can't spell couldn't return as the 9th doctor due to him being unavailable but John Hurt did a wonderful job as the War Doc.... ok, now i've realised the name is very lazy. The War doctor? Seriously? All Moffat did was put two letters in front of the Doctor's name.

Also, Clara fires an RPG at something. I really hope there is a damn good reason for her being turned into someone that can fire an RPG without any trouble!

As for the forced kiss, yeah, i think Moffat didn't realise that it was sexual assault and believed that it was one of Smith's quirks. Shame that he almost ruined Smith's run as the doctor with [&@%!] season stories.

John Hurt was great. But if they couldn't get Christopher Eccleston they could have always gone for Paul McGann who before The War Doctor showed up everyone just assumed was The Doctor during The Last Great Time War. You don't need to regenerate to change as a person. Although I did like Night of the Doctor.

That would have been perfect and would tie up the 8th Doctor's story instead of killing him off in a rather crap way. I mean, yes, he had a bit of a [&@%!] run due to BBC politics and not even getting his own series but he had a very successful comic run. And i just remembered that Russell T. Davies destroyed all of the comic book companions by forcing everything to be in line with the current series.

It would have shown us the Doctor's slow descent into the War doctor if they did it via comic books or a few episodes and would have given Mcgann the perfect chance to show his take on the doctor again.

I liked Night of the Doctor and whilst i felt that Smith's end was a bit cheap, it did resolve the whole limited regeneration process. Although, i swear that it was very vague and they could have gotten away with not really addressing it. Thankfully, Moffat did not force in River Song's "Sacrifice" by giving him a whole new regeneration cycle. I also suddenly want to punch something.

It begins on this Saturday! And I am not looking forward to it. I feel nothing towards it. :-/ Either MGS is responsible for that or i'm just not feeling it.

Apparently, Mistress is in the first episode, which is a bit of a waste but I hope they do a damn good job of explaining last season's thing it did with her.

I question why they had us think they died in the first place. Nobody, nobody thought that they were going to stay dead, Maybe Moffat just goes into withdrawals if he goes too long without killing a character in Doctor Who only to have them almost immediately come back to life.

Going to the theater tonight to watch the last two episodes of the past season (half season?) in 3D! 5 of us going, each dressed as a different Doctor. Well, I'm going to try. I got stuck with the War Doctor. I may just go as Rory or something instead >_>

They done [&@%!] it up! [&@%!] River Song is back! Sorry, sorry.

Anyway, hope you have fun, Musicman!

Also, Jenna Coleman has quit(again) so it seems that Clara will die or leave or disappear. Hopefully, someone other then moffat handles this as knowing him, he'll probably turn her into another plot device. River song was [&@%!] confirmed in the press release.

Actually decided to go as Captain Jack Harkness instead. bought a Vortex Manipulator and everything. Just need the jacket, but that's probably going to be impossible with such short notice. Oh well. Slacks, dress shirt with the sleeves rolled up, and suspenders will have to do.

And hitting on everything in sight. Just try not to get arrested.

But that's just what I do normally. :-/

Had a great time, though!

You need a bloke with a passing resemblence to John Simm, then have him dress up as Sam Tyler. Throw folks for a loop.

Then punch the person, knock them out and steal all of their cash! What?

No. You have them hit by a speeding car.