Oookay.... this way round is better than the alternative (for those that weren't watching, the MW article was originally transcluded here) but I'm not convinced that this is necessary. All that's on the page so far is MW-specific and so should remain confined to the MW-space. I can't speak for the earlier games but OB only added rumours to the lore on the matter. In that light, is it really necessary for a TAM article on this? –Rpeh•T•C•E• 17:56, 19 May 2008 (EDT)
- Well, as the creator, I'd say the criteria for Tamriel inclusion are met. If you read the main text, Slavery is mentioned in Books, it affects other regions and races, and there is conflicting position of the Imperial Cult. Slavery is historically and specifically been mentioned in the Armistice, many Morrowind and Vvardenfell document like PGE mentions the exception, so I'd say the article has a firm place in the Lore. That being said, Tamriel namespace is so fuzzy, I'd like to hear some clear arguments and guidelines. Further research will likely find more that can be included.
Books that talk about slavery: Lore:A Dance in Fire, Chapter 3, Lore:Blasphemous Revenants, Lore:King Edward, Part VII, Lore:King Edward, Part X, Lore:Last Scabbard of Akrash, Lore:The Marksmanship Lesson, Lore:Battle of Sancre Tor, Lore:The Argonian Account, Book 4, Lore:The Eastern Provinces, Lore:The Last King of the Ayleids
- Yes, I can use the search function too, but by the same criteria I could create a Tamriel:Sport article by mentioning The Book of Daedra and Words and Philosophy. Most of the books you list only mention slavery in passing, and the ones that go into detail were all introduced in Morrowind. The Imperial Cult is specific to Morrowind. It's true that it affects other provinces but the Tamriel NS isn't supposed to be Wikipedia, it's supposed to be for information relating to several games. If people want to know what slavery is they can look elsewhere. If they want to know about slavery in Morrowind, in which game it's quite important, they can look at MW:Slavery, and if they want to know how slavery affects other games, the phrase "It doesn't" springs to mind.
- You may have noticed several Tamriel pages being deleted because they have no relevance outside Daggerfall. Certainly the cities and provinces described would be relevant in the real world; people live there, they export items and are quite possibly great tourist destinations, but if they're not mentioned outside DF then there's no need for them to be mentioned in Tamriel. Slavery is mentioned outside MW, but the only game in which anything is affected by it is MW. That's why I don't think this article is necessary. –Rpeh•T•C•E• 01:02, 20 May 2008 (EDT)
- Don't get your argument about sports, that'd be a Reach. All you have to check is the Lore:Cyrodiil article: "The ancient Nedic, spreading south from Skyrim, became the slave labor for their ambitions, centered around the White Gold Tower."  One of the most important events of Cyrodilic history is the slave rebellion of the 242nd year of the First Era. The men and mer had been fighting in Skyrim for quite a while, however, this revolt, led by Alessia would represent a big win for men. "The heart of Tamriel was going to belong to these former slaves, present day Cyrodilics or Imperials, forever more." In an alliance with Skyrim, the Alessian Empire would push to the west towards High Rock, which, at the time, was the land of the Direnni. Another big change was present at this time, as described in A Pocket Guide to the Empire."
 Dwarven Slavery
Should the article be updated to include that the Dwemer used the Falmer as slaves? and then, later, the Falmer also kept slaves? Vos 22:39, 16 June 2012 (UTC)
- Sounds like a good idea to me. You can add it to the cleanup tag if you want. —Legoless 22:40, 16 June 2012 (UTC)
- Cheers Legoless. Vos 22:54, 16 June 2012 (UTC)
 Fourth Era
I'm not sure, but should this section be updated with information about slavery in the fourth era that we know? Right now it seems like its talking about the present state as the third era (TES 3). I think we know enough to at least write a small paragraph about the Argonian uprisings in Morrowind. Hope 20:09, 23 June 2012 (UTC)
- That's what the cleanup tag is there for. —Legoless 23:31, 23 June 2012 (UTC)
I was thinking about cleaning up this article, but what's the point? To reiterate some of the concerns in the conversation above, I don't think this article is necessary and it sets a bad precedent just by being here. We don't have an article on taxes, or civil liberties, or death, or the Tamrielic economy. I think we should be sticking to articles which can have a tangible focus - a person, a place, an organization, an event, etc. Stretching that focus out to a concept like what has been done here with slavery would vastly expand the number of articles we "should" have while providing very marginal edification for readers.
Further, concept-focused articles will often have an enormous scope, which means we would be spending enormous amounts of time researching, writing, and maintaining all of this information for insubstantial gain. Try doing a search here for "slave", and imagine combing through and analyzing all that data. It's just not practical. It might be different if a concept was some strange TES invention, but the real-world concept of slavery and the one held in TES are fundamentally the same. There's no need for us to reinvent the wheel on this. Minor EditsThreats•Evidence 00:14, 15 March 2013 (GMT)
- How about we straight copy the article to the morrowind namespace, and retool it to deal specifically with slavery in morrowind, since it is such a major part of the game. Would that work? Jeancey (talk) 00:15, 15 March 2013 (GMT)